Britain Today - Is Kindness In Decline?

A Reader's Digest/MORI poll reveals that around two thirds of people think Britain is a less caring place than ten years ago but the indications are that we are not so much hard-hearted as hard-headed.

A Reader's Digest/MORI poll reveals that around two thirds of people think Britain is a less caring place than ten years ago but the indications are that we are not so much hard-hearted as hard-headed.

Ten years on from a similar Reader's Digest/MORI survey, 1,979 adults were interviewed, providing a fascinating snapshot of our country as we enter a new millennium.

A Less Caring Britain

  • 63% of British adults think that Britain is less caring than a decade ago.
  • Four in ten people believe it will get worse over the next ten years.
  • People are more inclined to cite moral and spiritual reasons than ten years ago, including a decline in moral values (up 11 percentage points to 56%), the growth of materialism (also up 11 points to 43%) and the break-up of family life (up 10 points to 50%).
  • 12% had gone a full day without speaking to anyone and 14% reported feeling lonely at the weekend.

But British people are less concerned about the political state of the nation - only 15% blame government polices, as opposed to 25% ten years ago, and 26% point the finger at falling standards in schools, as against 36% in 1989.

A More Canny Britain

  • The number of people approached by someone begging in a public place has risen dramatically from 25% in 1989 to 59% in 1999. In London the figure was 80%; in Yorkshire and the Humber it was 70%.
  • 62% of those who had been approached gave nothing to beggars, but 73% overall say they gave money to charity.
  • Half the public now agree that many of those on State benefit do not genuinely need such help, an increase of 16 percentage points on 1989.
  • 88% feel that people should be encouraged to stand on their own two feet.
  • 63% dreamt about winning the Lottery at least once a month. Such fantasies are most prevalent in the East Midlands - 74% - and least so in London - 55%.

"Our poll paints a realistic picture of life in Britain at the end of the millennium," says Russell Twisk, Editor-in-Chief of Reader's Digest. "We selfishly dream of the Lottery and expect people to look after themselves. But there are encouraging signs for the future. More than a fifth of people questioned did voluntary work and we give generously to charity. Maybe it's simply that we are caring - but we're canny too."

Caring Society 1989 - 1999 Topline Results

  • 1,979 Adults Aged 15+
  • Interviewed Face-To-Face, In-Home
  • Between 10-13 September 1999
  • In 160 Sampling Points Throughout Great Britain
  • An Asterisk (*) Indicates A Percentage Less Than 0.5% But Greater Than Zero
  • Data Have Been Weighted To Reflect The National Profile
  • Trends With The 1989 Caring Society Research Are Incorporated
  • This Research Was Conducted Among 1,986 Adults 15+, Between 18-22 May 1989, In 146 Sampling Points

I would now like to talk about doing things for other people.

Q1 On this card is a list of things people can do to help others. Which, if any, of these have you done in the past six months? Do not include things you have done for a member of your family?

 19891999Diff '89-'99
 %%±
Helped an elderly or disabled person to cross the street3423-11
Visited someone elderly, ill or disabled to see if they are all right3732-5
Done some shopping for an elderly, ill or disabled person2623-3
Given up your seat to someone else on public transport3029-1
Chatted to someone you thought was lonely4641-5
Taken part in a sponsored walk or other fund-raising event1813-5
Given money to charity7273+1
Other52-3
None of these78+1
Don't know**0

Any9290-2
Two or more7265-7
Three or more4942-5

Q2 Have you done any voluntary work in the past year, or not?

 19891999Diff '89-'99
 %%±
Yes2022+2
No7978-1
Don't know1*-1

Q3 How many of your neighbours have you spoken to in the last week, if any?

 19891999Diff '89-'99
 %%±
None610+4
1-22226+4
3-425250
5-62119-2
7-101412-2
More than 10118-3
Don't know / can't remember81-7
Mean5.94.8-1.1

Q4 Thinking about how life in Britain has changed over the past ten years, do you think that people are now …

 19891999Diff '89-'99
 %%±
More caring1611-5
or less caring6063+3
About the same / don't know2426+2

Q5 Which of these, if any, do you think are the main reasons why people have become less caring?

Q6 And for which other reasons, if any, do you think people have become less caring?

 Q5 MainQ5/6 Total
 19891999Diff '89-'9919891999Diff '89-'99
 %%±%%±
Attitudes of young people2231+94250+8
Over-reliance on the Welfare State814+62126+5
Break-up of family life1728+114050+10
Lack of discipline from parents2438+145762+5
Falling standards in schools1114+33626-10
Decline of religion511+62122+1
Decline in moral values1735+184556+11
Government policies118-32515-10
Growth in materialism1428+143243+11
Influence of television1220+84041+1
Influence of newspapers46+21815-3
Poor example set by public figures715+82432+8
Other37+4611+5
Don't know21-1110
None of these*1+10*0

Q7 Which of these, if any, do you think are the main reasons why people have become more caring?

Q8 And for which other reasons, if any, do you think people have become more caring?

 Q7 MainQ8 Total
 19891999Diff '89-'9919891999Diff '89-'99
 %%±%%±
Attitudes of young people2018-23629-7
Better standards in schools69+31319+6
More discipline from parents76-11411-3
People are better-off141402423-1
More awareness of problems5161+107273+1
Influence of television2231+95244-8
Influence of newspapers613+723230
Less State support85-31610-6
Other28+6413+9
Don't know33030-3
None of these*0013+2

Q9 And how do you think life in Britain might change over the next ten years into the new Millennium? Do you think that people will be …

 %
More caring16
or less caring41
About the same / don't know43

Q10 Please could you tell me to what extent you agree or disagree with the following statements.

 Strongly agree/ Tend to agreeTend to disagree/ Strongly disagree
 19891999Diff '89-'9919891999Diff '89-'99
 %%±%%±
People should be encouraged to stand on their own two feet8988-134+1
Over the last ten years, the rich have got richer and the poor have got poorer757501513-2
Many of those receiving State benefit do not genuinely need such help3450+164331-12
The emphasis of responsibility for caring for the elderly should be shifted away from the State and towards the public through charities1013+37574-1

Q11 In the last six months, have you been approached by someone begging in a public place?

 19891999Diff '89-'99
 %%±
Yes2559+34
No7440-34
Don't know / can't remember**0

Q12 Thinking about the last time you were approached by someone begging, how much, if anything, did you give to them?

 %
Nothing62
£0.01 - £0.04*
£0.05 - £0.092
£0.10 - £0.191
£0.20 - £0.498
£0.50 - £0.996
£1.00 - £1.9915
£2.00 - £2.993
£3.00 - £3.99*
£4.00 - £4.99*
£5.00 - £9.991
£10.00 or more0
Don't know / can't remember2
Any money35
Average£0.47

Q13 Which, if any, of these situations have you experienced in the last year?

 19891999Diff '89-'99
 %%±
Gone a full day without anyone speaking to you1112+1
Had a birthday on which you received no presents54-1
Felt lonely at the weekend1314+1
Been left on your own needing help for more than six hours34+1
Spent Christmas alone34+1
Telephoned the Samaritans or other emergency helpline12+1
None of these7475+1
Don't know1*-1

Q14 On average, how often, if at all, would you say you daydream about winning the National Lottery jackpot?

 %
Practically non stop4
About every hour1
About every two - three hours1
A few times a day2
About once or twice a day6
A few times a week11
About once a week20
A few times a month4
About once a month6
Less often than once a month8
Never (but do play the Lottery)12
Never / don't play the Lottery / not applicable23
Don't know1
At least once or twice a day14
A few times a week - at least once a month41
Ever63

Technical details

MORI interviewed a representative quota sample of 1,979 adults aged 15+ in 160 sampling points throughout Great Britain. Interviews were conducted face-to-face, in-home, between 10 and 13 September 1999. Data have been weighted to the national profile.

Related news