The shifting political landscape of what we trust

Who (and what) Americans trust is split along political lines, according to the Ipsos Consumer Tracker: While large majorities tend to believe eyewitness accounts, Republicans are now more likely to believe eyewitnesses than Democrats.

The Ipsos Consumer Tracker asks Americans questions about culture, the economy and the forces that shape our lives. Here's one thing we learned this week.

Why we asked about trust: AI and deepfakes have us doubting … just about everything we see, hear and watch. But has it led to shifts in what we trust? Back in 2020 we fielded a survey for What the Future’s Truth issue. So we trended a key question there about the sources we are confident in. 

What we found: There were some shifts, for sure, from 2020 when we fielded this question last. And interestingly, they showed up most prominently in the party identification splits. While large majorities tend to believe eyewitness accounts, there is a newfound party split with Republicans now more likely to believe eyewitnesses than Democrats. Democrats are now more likely to believe statements from government officials (59% to 35%), which is a big reversal from August 2020 when it was 45% to 33%. Granted, there’s been a reversal in the government officials, too. And while there is still high confidence in government records, there is a partisan split opening there, too. Democrats are now more likely to believe advertising. And Democrats are FAR more likely to believe academics and researchers, which was the case in 2020. We added a couple of items this wave about videos and photos we see on social media, and few claim confidence in either. 

More insights from this wave of the Ipsos Consumer Tracker:

Fewer think AI is coming for white collar jobs

One in ten think the Supreme Court will decide the Presidential election

Many report economic anxiety and spending shifts during election season

People with higher incomes have more expectation of generational wealth

The Ipsos Care-O-Meter: What does America know about vs. what does America care about? 
 

The author(s)

Related news

  • Nine trends that explain 2025
    Polling Survey

    Nine trends that explain 2025

    As 2025 winds down, Ipsos looks back on what was an eventful year. From the economy to artificial intelligence, here are the big trends that shaped the past year
  • Polling Survey

    Optimism will prevail

    Below are five charts on how Americans felt about 2025, America’s predictions for 2026, and Americans’ optimism about their own lives
  • Picture of woman with confetti raining down

    Americans resolve to make 2026 better

    "Saving more money" is the most popular New Year's resolution for 2026, according to new data from the Ipsos Consumer Tracker