Eastern Eye - Survey of British Asians' Attitudes

Eastern Eye Survey Confirms The Loyalty Of British Asians

Eastern Eye Survey Confirms The Loyalty Of British Asians

A major opinion poll published this week by Eastern Eye, Britain's biggest selling Asian newspaper, shows that British Asians are overwhelmingly loyal to the country in the current action against terrorism. The survey was carried out by MORI, on behalf of the newspaper, with face-to-face interviews with 554 Hindus, Muslims, Sikhs and Christians before and after the defeat of the Taleban in Kabul.

The survey shows that:

  • 90% of British Asians are loyal to the country in the war against terrorism
  • Among Muslims alone 87% say they are loyal to Britain, even though 64% oppose the US-led strikes against Afghanistan.
  • Loyalty to the country is almost equally strong among both young and old, squashing the myth that young Asians are a 'problem group' in the light of recent riots in Oldham and Bradford.

Among other findings:

  • 54% of Asians think the US-led alliance is right to bring down the Taleban regime in Afghanistan and 62 per cent of Muslims say British followers of extremist groups are wrong to go and fight for the Taleban.
  • Half of all those interviewed want to see any British Muslims fighting in Afghanistan put on trial for treason if they return to the UK.

The poll shows concern over race relations in Britain, which most fear have worsened since the events of September 11. There are signs of differences within the Asian community, although 70 per cent of Hindus and Sikhs say their view of the Muslims community has not changed since September 11. 80 per cent of Hindus and 72 per cent of Sikhs want to see extremist Muslim groups banned in Britain, but this view is supported by only 38 per cent of Muslims.

Support for Tony Blair's handling of the British response among Hindus and Sikhs is higher than the national average, with 66 per cent of Hindus and 74 per cent of Sikhs backing the Prime Minister. Among Muslims, however, support for Blair falls to 32 per cent.

The survey was welcomed by Asian leaders, among them Ashok Kumar, MP for Middlesborough South and East Cleveland, who said: "Asians are as loyal as anybody else in this country. They identify with Britain and what it stands for."

Technical details

  • MORI interviewed 554 GB Asian adults aged 16+
  • Interviews were conducted face-to-face, in street or in-home between 10 - 14 November 2001
  • Interviews were conducted in 38 parliamentary constituencies with an Asian population of greater than 9%
  • Results are based on all respondents (554) unless otherwise stated. The sample includes 116 Hindus, 319 Muslims, 100 Sikhs, 11 Christians and 4 people identifying with another religion and 4 people refusing or not stating the religion with which they identify. Each question shows the responses given by all Hindus, Muslims and Sikhs
  • Data are weighted by age, gender and work status using 1996 ONS mid-year population estimates and the labour force survey to the known population profile of GB Asian adults
  • An '*' indicates a finding of less than 0.5%, but greater than zero
  • Where percentages do not add up to exactly 100% this may be due to computer rounding, the exclusion of "don't knows" or to multiple answers

Results

Q1 Do you approve or disapprove of the way Tony Blair is handling the British response to the terrorist attacks on 11th September?
 AllHinduMuslimSikh
 (554)(116)(319)(100)
 %%%%
Approve48663274
Disapprove34175012
Don't know18171814
Comparisons from national polls asking the same question to the general public

 

Q2 The United States and Britain launched military strikes against Afghanistan in response to the terrorist attacks on 11th September. Do you support or oppose taking action against Afghanistan?
 AllHinduMuslimSikh
 (554)(116)(319)(100)
 %%%%
Support39662058
Oppose46196431
Don't know15161611
Comparisons from national polls asking the same question to the general public

 

Q3 Do you think that race relations in Britain have got better, worse or stayed the same following the events of September 11th?
 AllHinduMuslimSikh
 (554)(116)(319)(100)
 %%%%
Got better4438
Got worse52475747
Stayed the same37403442
Don't know7396

 

Q4 To what extent do you agree or disagree that the events following September 11th have created divisions within the Asian communities of Britain?
 AllHinduMuslimSikh
 (554)(116)(319)(100)
 %%%%
Strongly agree1112138
Tend to agree33273337
Neither agree nor disagree19281620
Tend to disagree20162025
Strongly disagree95127
Don't know71164

 

Q5 Can I just check, which of these religious groups, if any, do you identify with?
 %
Sikh21
Hindu22
Muslim54
Christian2
None of these1
Refused*

 

Q6 Do you think that the events following September 11th make you view the Muslim community more or less favourably or has your view not changed?
Base:Hindus and SikhsHinduSikh
 (216)(116)(100)
 %%%
More favourably232
Less favourably231828
Not changed707465
Don't know214
Not stated241

 

Q7 Do you think that the events following September 11th have made other Asian communities such as Hindus and Sikhs view the Muslim community more or less favourably, or do you think their view has not changed?
Base:All Muslim
 (319)
 %
More favourably2
Less favourably29
Not changed57
Don't Know11
Not stated1

 

Q8 Looking at this card, how loyal, if at all, would you say you are to Britain?
 AllHinduMuslimSikh
 (554)(116)(319)(100)
 %%%%
Very loyal49624255
Fairly loyal41304540
Not very loyal5464
Not at all loyal1020
Don't know4351
Not stated*100

 

Q9 Looking at this card, which country do you consider to be the country of origin of your family?
 AllHinduMuslimSikh
 (554)(116)(319)(100)
 %%%%
Bangladesh73120
India46871293
Pakistan332601
Sri Lanka13*0
United Kingdom7484
Other6192

 

Q10 Looking at this card, to what extent, if any, do you feel the terrorist attacks on the World Trade Centre and the Pentagon in the United States on September 11th were justified?
 AllHinduMuslimSikh
 (554)(116)(319)(100)
 %%%%
A great deal223*
A fair amount5449
Not very much1031310
Not at all72806775
Don't know98116
Not stated2221

 

Q11 On this card are two statements. Please tell me which one comes closest to your personal view?
 AllHinduMuslimSikh
 (554)(116)(319)(100)
 %%%%
The military strikes on Afghanistan are a war against Islam217351
The military strikes on Afghanistan are a war against terrorism58753988
Neither119171
Don't know910910
Not stated1010

 

Q12 Do you think that the United States and Britain are right or wrong to try and bring down the Taliban regime?
 AllHinduMuslimSikh
 (554)(116)(319)(100)
 %%%%
Right54773379
Wrong266429
Don't know20172511
Not stated1011

 

Q13 Do you think that Osama bin Laden is right or wrong in launching a series of terrorist attacks against western targets?
 AllHinduMuslimSikh
 (554)(116)(319)(100)
 %%%%
Right4171
Wrong78896794
Don't know168245
Not stated2220

 

Q14 Are young British Muslims right or wrong to go to Afghanistan to fight alongside the Taliban?
 AllHinduMuslimSikh
 (554)(116)(319)(100)
 %%%%
Right92151
Wrong72796289
Don't know18192110
Not stated1110

 

Q15 Some people have suggested that any British Muslims who go to Afghanistan to fight for the Taliban should be prosecuted for treason if they return to this country. Do you support or oppose this idea?
 10-14 Nov1-2 Nov*
 AllHinduMuslimSikh
 (554)(116)(319)(100)
 %%%%%
Support5074347071
Oppose2915431019
Don't know209232010
Not stated11110
*Comparison from a nationally representative poll conducted by telephone among general public

 

Q16 Do you support or oppose banning extremist Muslim groups in Britain?
 AllHinduMuslimSikh
 (554)(116)(319)(100)
 %%%%
Support54803872
Oppose2593612
Don't know19102513
Not stated2113

 

Q17 The views of extremist British Muslims have received a lot of attention recently. Do you think the majority of the British Muslim community have done too much, too little or about the right amount in speaking out against the views of the extremists.
 AllHinduMuslimSikh
 (554)(116)(319)(100)
 %%%%
Too much71156
Too little39423938
The right amount23132722
Don't know30332733
Not stated1110

Comparison Key

More insights about Culture

Society