Ipsos Delivery Index Budget Briefing

Alistair Darling delivers his first Budget as Chancellor this week having faced a number of difficulties since entering 11 Downing Street last summer, such as an economic slowdown and criticism of his handling of Northern Rock.

And Labour has lost its lead as the best party to get value for public money

Alistair Darling delivers his first Budget as Chancellor this week having faced a number of difficulties since entering 11 Downing Street last summer, such as an economic slowdown and criticism of his handling of Northern Rock. These difficulties are reflected by almost half of the public (44%) being dissatisfied with his Chancellorship, while fewer than three in ten (28%) are satisfied.

Darling's first ratings are similar to Gordon Brown's final ratings as Chancellor and similar to those of previous Conservative Chancellors (who, like Darling, assumed the role in the middle of a Parliamentary term). They are nevertheless far behind the first ratings of previous Labour Chancellors Brown and Denis Healey.

Labour has lost its lead as the party best able to get good value from the public money it spends. The public are now split between the Labour and the Conservatives on this issue, whereas just before the 2005 General Election Labour was 11 points ahead of the Conservatives. This will be a crucial issue ahead of the next General Election, given the similarity of the two main parties' economic policies and widespread perceptions that there is little economic room to manoeuvre in the current financial climate.

Pessimism towards the economy has however grown in recent months, reflecting the range of economic difficulties facing the UK. Indeed, more of the public have been viewing the economy as a key issue facing Britain across recent months, and the battle over the prized asset of economic competence will be a vital one for the main parties in deciding the outcome of the next General Election.

Bearing in mind the possibility of 'Green Taxes' forming part of Darling's Budget, it is interesting that more of the public are pessimistic than optimistic on the government's ability to tackle climate change. Nevertheless, more of the public are positive about this than they are on other key issues facing the government, such as crime, pensions and immigration.

The public's mood on the future of public services remains pessimistic overall, although the situation has at least stabilised in recent months. There are also some signs of an increasingly positive mood on the NHS and on opportunities for young people. Education continues to be the government's flagship.

Topline Results

  • Ipsos interviewed 1,012 British adults 18+
  • Fieldwork conducted by telephone between 7-9 March 2008
  • Data weighted to the national population profile
  • An '*' indicates a finding of less than 0.5%, but greater than zero
  • Where percentages do not add up to exactly 100% this is due to computer rounding, the exclusion of "don't knows" or to multiple answers
  • Download the data tabulations pdf, 380KB

Q1 Do you think a Labour or Conservative Government would be most effective in getting good value for the public money it spends?

Base: All 18+

  Apr 2005 Mar 2008
  % %
Labour Government 41 27
Conservative Government 30 29
Other 4 3
None 13 22
Don't know 12 19

Q2 On balance, do you agree or disagree with the statement that in the long term, this government's policies will improve the state of Britain's public services?

Base: All 18+

  Nov 2007 Mar 2008
  % %
Agree 34 33
Disagree 54 55
Don't know 12 12
Net agree -20 -22

Q3-7 Thinking about ... over the next few years do you expect it to ... ?

Base: All 18+

  The NHS The quality of education Public transport Opportunities for young people Skills in Britain's workforce
  Nov '07 Mar '08 Nov '07 Mar '08 Nov '07 Mar '08 Nov '07 Mar '08 Sept '07 Mar '08
  % % % % % % % % % %
Get much better 2 4 4 3 3 3 3 4 3 4
Get better 21 22 27 30 26 26 23 28 23 24
Stay the same 37 35 42 38 38 37 37 31 38 34
Get worse 28 25 19 19 24 22 28 25 26 24
Get much worse 11 12 4 5 5 8 6 8 6 8
Don't know 2 3 3 5 5 5 3 4 4 6
 
Better 23 26 31 33 29 29 26 32 26 28
Worse 39 37 23 24 29 30 34 33 32 32
 
Net better -16 -11 +8 +9 0 -1 -8 -1 -6 -4

Q8-11 How confident, if at all, are you the government will ... in the next few years?

Base: All 18+

  Control and manage immigration Deal with climate change Do the right thing about pensions Listen to people's priorities
  Sept '07 Mar '08 Sept '07 Mar '08 Sept '07 Mar '08 Sept '07 Mar '08
  % % % % % % % %
Very confident 3 5 5 6 2 5 4 3
Fairly confident 17 20 33 33 21 18 26 22
Not very confident 34 31 36 35 40 42 38 39
Not at all confident 42 40 21 21 31 31 30 33
Don't know 4 4 5 5 5 5 3 3
 
Very/fairly confident 20 25 38 39 23 23 30 25
Not very/not at all confident 76 71 57 56 71 73 68 72
 
Net confident -56 -46 -19 -17 -48 -50 -38 -47

Q12 Please tell me whether you are confident in the current government, or not, when it comes to cracking down on crime and violence?

Base: All 18+ (split sample - 510)

  %
Yes, confident 30
No, not confident 67
Don't know 3

Q13 Can you tell me whether you are satisfied or dissatisfied with the way Alistair Darling is doing his job as Chancellor of the Exchequer?

Base: All 18+

  %
Satisfied 28
Dissatisfied 44
Don't know 28

More insights about Public Sector

Society